Are they a problem, and when do they need attention?
Many of my patients in Buderim are familiar with old-style amalgam fillings – fillings that appear silver, grey or black in colour. Patients have often had these fillings since childhood or their teenage years, and in most cases, without any problems.
Amalgam has been used as a filling material for about 200 years. It was the predominant material used by dentists for much of this time, before tooth-coloured alternatives became available and widely used.
Dental amalgam is made from elemental liquid mercury mixed with an alloy containing mainly silver, tin and copper. Together, these form a hard, durable filling material. Amalgam has been very effective at restoring teeth for many years. But, are these old fillings a problem?
The answer: it depends!
The material itself
Although amalgam contains mercury, major dental and health authorities generally consider intact amalgam fillings safe for most people. The presence of mercury alone is not usually a reason to remove a filling that is functioning well. In fact, removing an intact amalgam filling can actually inadvertently release additional material. It may also involve removing sound tooth structure, so replacement should be based on the condition of the filling and tooth, rather than concern about mercury alone.
There may be specific circumstances in which your dentist recommends avoiding or replacing amalgam, such as a known allergy to its components or particular medical considerations. If you are pregnant, breastfeeding, have concerns about mercury exposure, or have been advised to avoid amalgam for another reason, discuss this with your dentist and doctor before making a decision.
Cracks and Decay
Teeth containing amalgam fillings can develop cracks over time. Conventional amalgam fillings rely on the shape of the preparation to stay in place, rather than sticking to the tooth. Depending on the size of the filling and how much tooth structure remains, the surrounding tooth can also be vulnerable to cracking.
However, cracks may or may not be a problem. Like a chip in a car windscreen, they can be small and superficial, or they can extend further. Deeper cracks can lead to tooth fracture or damage to the nerve, sometimes resulting in tooth loss.
If a tooth has an amalgam filling that is in good condition, with no decay or concerning cracks, it may not need replacing at all. Every time a tooth is drilled, there is some risk of irritating or damaging the nerve. However, significant cracks, particularly those associated with symptoms such as sensitivity to hot or cold, or pain when biting, may need attention.
So, how do we decide what to do?
During your regular examination, we assess the tooth and its filling using illumination and magnification. We look for visible cracks, signs of decay and the amount of remaining tooth structure.
X-rays and photographs can help us assess and monitor the tooth. We also take a detailed history of any symptoms, including pain when biting and sensitivity to hot or cold.
Your tooth with the silver filling may not require any treatment—just monitoring. However, if it is structurally compromised, we may recommend a restoration such as a crown, onlay or filling, depending on what the tooth needs.
Fortunately, modern dentistry offers materials such as tooth-coloured composite resin and ceramics, including lithium disilicate and zirconia. With appropriate treatment, we can often restore and protect weakened teeth, helping you keep them for longer.